Warm Homes, Sweet Traditions: Chicagoland’s Best Holiday Pies (2025 Guide)
11/19/2025
Space Matter Group — Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Chicago
The holidays in Chicago are all about warm kitchens, good food, and time with the people who
make a house feel like home. To celebrate the season, we’ve put together our favorite holiday
pie picks for families across Chicago, Oak Park, Berwyn, and the surrounding suburbs.
Whether you’re hosting Thanksgiving, attending Friendsgiving, or just craving something sweet,
these pies are perfect for your holiday table.
Top Holiday Pie Picks in Chicago
1. Sara Lee Apple Pie - A Midwest classic with a flaky crust and warm apple filling.
- Order on Amazon (CLICK HERE)
2. Marie Callender’s Pumpkin - A go-to for Chicago families looking for a reliable,
delicious holiday dessert.
- Shop on Amazon (CLICK HERE)
3. Bird-in-Hand Shoofly Pie - A true homemade-style dessert from a small Amish bakery
in Pennsylvania. Rich, sweet, and perfect for “cozy holiday season” vibes across Chicagoland.
- Order Bird-in-Hand Shoofly Pie (CLICK HERE)
For Chicago Home Bakers: King Arthur Baking Pie Recipes
If you prefer to bake your own holiday desserts, King Arthur Baking offers incredible recipes and
ingredients trusted by home bakers everywhere.
Best Page for Holiday Baking: King Arthur Pie Recipes Collection
This page includes:
- Apple pie
- Pumpkin pie
- Pecan pie
- Chocolate & cream pies
- Dozens of seasonal favorites
Explore King Arthur’s Pie Recipes (CLICK HERE)
Home for the Holidays with Space Matter Group
As a BHHS Chicago team, we’re here to support Chicagoland families with their real estate
goals this season, whether you’re preparing for a move or dreaming of a new home for 2025.
Free Holiday Consultation
We're offering complimentary home consultations through December, perfect for anyone
thinking about buying, selling, or investing.